roofers
How to Choose a Roofer in Illinois by Reading the Quote, the License and the Warranty
How to choose a roofer in Illinois: verify the IDFPR license, compare written quotes line by line, and read the warranty before you sign for your new roof.
In This Article
How to Choose a Roofer in Illinois by Reading the Quote, the License and the Warranty
Three roofers walk the same Naperville house and hand back bids of $11,800, $14,200 and $19,500. The homeowner's first instinct is to throw out the high one and take the low one. Six years later, the low bid is the one leaking at the chimney, and the warranty turns out to cover shingles but not the labor to replace them.
Choosing a roofer in Illinois mostly comes down to reading paper well. The state license tells you who is allowed to do the work, the estimate tells you what they plan to do, and the warranty tells you who pays when something goes wrong. Learn to compare those three documents and the right contractor usually becomes obvious.
Start With the State License
Illinois is one of the states that licenses roofers at the state level. Under the Illinois Roofing Industry Licensing Act, roofing contractors are licensed through the Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation, known as IDFPR. Residential work falls under a limited license, while an unlimited license covers commercial and industrial jobs as well.
You can look up any roofer's license on the IDFPR website in a couple of minutes. Search by company name or license number and confirm the status is active and the name on the license matches the name on the bid. A roofer who hesitates to give you a license number, or gives you one that belongs to a different business, should drop off your list right there.
The license number should also appear on the company's written bid and contract. If it is missing from the paperwork, ask why before you go any further.
Then Check What the City Adds
State licensing is the floor. Chicago, Naperville, Peoria, Springfield and most suburbs also require a building permit for a full roof replacement, and some municipalities keep their own contractor registration lists. Check with your city or village building department, since rules in Cook County suburbs can change from one border street to the next.
Chicago deserves its own note. The city has a huge share of brick bungalows, two-flats and three-flats, many with flat or low-slope roofs hidden behind a parapet wall. Those roofs need a contractor who works with membranes like modified bitumen, TPO or built-up roofing, and the city has its own permit process for that work.
Insurance matters at every level. Ask for a certificate of general liability insurance sent directly from the insurer, and confirm workers' compensation coverage for the crew. A roofer who falls from a Peoria two-story without coverage can turn into a claim against your homeowner's policy.
How to Read an Illinois Roofing Estimate
A good estimate reads like a recipe. It names the materials, the quantities, and each step, so you could hand it to another roofer and get the same roof. A vague estimate lists a total and a shingle color.
Line the bids up side by side on the kitchen table. Most of the price gap between Illinois roofers comes from five or six items, and the cheapest bid almost always trims at least two of them. When you see the same scope on paper, the real price difference often shrinks.
Here is what each written quote should spell out clearly:
- Tear-off of all existing layers and disposal, with the number of layers stated
- Decking inspection and a per-sheet price for replacing damaged plywood or planks
- Ice and water shield at eaves, valleys and around penetrations, with coverage noted
- Synthetic underlayment over the rest of the deck
- New drip edge, step flashing and chimney flashing rather than reused metal
- Ventilation plan with intake and exhaust products named
- Shingle brand, product line and color
- Permit fees, cleanup and magnetic nail sweep
The decking line
Older homes in Chicago, Evanston, Oak Park and Springfield often have plank decking or plywood that has taken decades of ice dams. Nobody knows how much of it is bad until the old shingles come off. A fair quote handles that uncertainty with a per-sheet price, often somewhere around $70 to $120 a sheet installed.
A quote that skips the line completely leaves room for a surprise change order halfway through the job. A quote that bakes in a large lump sum may be overcharging. The per-sheet number is the one you can hold a roofer to.
Ice barrier and flashing
Illinois winters are long, and northern Illinois sees enough snow and freeze-thaw to make ice dams common. Building codes adopted around the state generally call for an ice barrier at the eaves, but how far up the roof it goes varies by contractor. Two rows instead of one can cost a little more and save a ceiling.
Flashing is the other spot where cheap bids save money. Reusing old step flashing against a brick chimney is fast, and it is the source of a large share of leaks in older Chicago-area homes.
Comparing Price Without Getting Fooled
Most Illinois homeowners pay roughly $10,000 to $18,000 for an architectural asphalt replacement on an average suburban house. A small Chicago bungalow with a pitched main roof might come in lower, while a large Naperville two-story with steep pitches and multiple valleys can run past $20,000. Flat roofs on two-flats are usually quoted per square, and prices vary with the membrane chosen.
When one bid sits far below the others, go back to the list above and check which items it leaves out. When one sits far above, ask the roofer to walk you through it, because sometimes it includes a better underlayment, extended warranty or ventilation fix that the others skipped. Price per square, meaning per 100 square feet of roof, is the easiest way to compare apples to apples.
Payment terms belong in the comparison too. A small deposit for materials is normal. A roofer who wants half or more in cash before work starts is a risk, and Illinois law generally requires a written contract for home repair jobs over $1,000, along with a consumer rights brochure the contractor should hand you.
Reading the Warranty Fine Print
Every new roof comes with two warranties that people often confuse. The manufacturer's warranty covers defects in the shingles themselves. The workmanship warranty, from the roofer, covers installation mistakes, which cause the majority of early roof failures.
Manufacturer warranties often advertise 30 years, 50 years, or "lifetime," but the full coverage usually lasts only the first 10 years or so before it starts prorating. Many basic warranties also exclude labor and disposal costs. Enhanced warranties, available only through certified installers, can extend non-prorated coverage and include labor, and they usually require the roofer to use a full system of matching products.
Workmanship warranties range from one year to 10 years or more. Ask how long it lasts, whether it transfers if you sell, and what happens if the company closes. A 10-year workmanship promise from a company that started last spring is worth less than a five-year one from a firm with two decades in Peoria.
Turning the Winning Quote Into a Contract
Once you pick a bid, the contract should repeat every line from the estimate and add the business details. That means the company's legal name and address, the IDFPR license number, a start window and expected finish date, and a payment schedule tied to progress. Anything the salesperson promised out loud, like a second row of ice barrier or new gutters, belongs in writing.
Ask who will be on the roof and who supervises them. Some Illinois companies sell the job and hand it to a subcontracted crew, which is common and not a problem if the license holder stays responsible for the work. You should know the name of the person to call if the crew leaves a mess or a nail ends up in your driveway.
Before the final payment, request lien waivers from the roofer and the material supplier. Those papers confirm everyone has been paid, so no supplier can put a lien on your Springfield or Naperville house over a bill the contractor skipped.
Timing and Scheduling in Illinois
Spring and fall are the busiest seasons for roofers across the state. After a hail storm in the western suburbs or a summer wind event around Bloomington, the established local firms can book weeks out. Booking in late winter for a spring install often gets you better crew availability.
Winter jobs happen in Illinois, but cold weather affects how shingles seal. If you have a leak in January, ask for a repair or temporary fix and plan the full replacement for warmer weather. You can find more seasonal advice in our homeowner guides on the blog.
When you are ready to build a short list, the roofers directory for your area lets you compare licensed local contractors in one place.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do roofers need a license in Illinois?
Yes. Roofing contractors in Illinois need a license from IDFPR under the Roofing Industry Licensing Act, and you can verify it online in a few minutes before you sign.
How many roofing quotes should I get in Chicago?
Three written quotes is a good target for most Chicago homeowners. Ask each roofer to price the same scope, including tear-off, decking per sheet and flashing, so the totals mean something.
What is a fair workmanship warranty in Illinois?
Many established Illinois roofers offer somewhere between five and 10 years on workmanship. Ask whether it transfers to a buyer, since that can help when you sell a house in a market like Naperville.
Can I put shingles on my flat Chicago roof?
No, asphalt shingles are not made for flat or very low-slope roofs and will leak. Those sections need a membrane system such as modified bitumen, TPO or EPDM installed by a roofer who does that type of work regularly.